SRINAGAR: The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has dismissed the appeal of Younis Mushtaq Bhat, accused in the 2022 Kakapora railway station attack in which two police personnel were killed, holding that the material collected during the investigation provides reasonable grounds to believe that the accusations against him under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) are prima facie true.
A division bench of Justice Sanjeev Kumar and Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani observed that the statutory restrictions on granting bail under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA were attracted in the case, leaving no ground to interfere with the trial court’s decision to reject his bail application.
The judgment, authored by Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani, was pronounced on November 18, 2026, after the matter was reserved for judgment on November 13.
Bhat had challenged an order dated November 17, 2025, passed by the Special Court (Additional Sessions Judge), Pulwama, which had rejected his bail plea in FIR No. 29/2022 registered at Police Station Kakapora under various provisions of the IPC, Arms Act and UAPA.
The case dates back to April 18, 2022, when police received information about firing at Kakapora railway station, resulting in the on-the-spot death of Head Constable Surinder Singh and injuries to other police personnel. Sub-Inspector Dev Raj, who was injured in the incident, later succumbed to his injuries at a hospital on April 23, 2022.
During the investigation, police obtained CCTV footage from railway authorities, which reportedly helped identify several suspects, including Bhat, also known as Imtiaz.
According to the prosecution’s account reproduced in the judgment, Bhat initially denied his involvement but admitted it when confronted with the CCTV footage. He was subsequently arrested on April 23, 2022.
The investigation further alleged that Bhat, in his disclosure statement recorded before an Executive Magistrate, described how he had accompanied co-accused Mukhtar Maqbool Bhat on a motorcycle to the railway station on the day of the attack.
As per the prosecution version, Mukhtar allegedly opened fire on two Railway Protection Force personnel who were having tea at a table, while Bhat remained near the entry point with the motorcycle in a running position. The two then allegedly fled towards Sangoo Narbal.
The investigation also brought the names of Tawheed Bashir Bhat and Reyaz Ahmad Dar into the case. A chargesheet was filed against four accused. Proceedings under Section 299 of the CrPC were initiated against Mukhtar Maqbool Bhat and Reyaz Ahmad Dar, who, according to the prosecution, could not be arrested.
The trial court framed charges against Younis Mushtaq Bhat under Sections 18 and 39 of the UAPA on December 27, 2022. By the time his bail application was rejected in November 2025, the prosecution had examined 17 of the 42 listed witnesses.
Challenging the rejection of bail, Bhat’s counsel, Advocate Adil Pandit, argued that his client had been falsely implicated and that there was no substantial evidence establishing his involvement in the alleged offences under Sections 18 and 39 of the UAPA.
The defence maintained that no recovery had been made from Bhat or at his instance to substantiate the alleged conspiracy. It also questioned the reliance on the alleged extra-judicial confession, arguing that it could not be relied upon in the absence of any subsequent recovery or discovery of a new fact.
Pandit further argued that Bhat had remained in custody since April 23, 2022, and that his prolonged incarceration, coupled with the slow pace of the trial, violated his fundamental right to liberty and speedy trial under Article 21 of the Constitution.
He submitted that nearly half of the prosecution witnesses were yet to be examined and the trial could take several more years to conclude. The defence also argued that the statutory restrictions under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA needed to be balanced against the accused’s constitutional right to liberty.
To support his arguments, the defence relied upon Supreme Court judgments in Union of India versus K A Najeeb, National Investigation Agency versus Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali and Gurvinder Singh versus State of Punjab.
Opposing the appeal, Senior Additional Advocate General Mohsin Qadri, assisted by Advocate Maha Majeed, argued that the material collected during the investigation and evidence recorded during the trial established a prima facie case against Bhat.
The government counsel submitted that CCTV footage had led to the identification of Bhat and that he admitted his involvement when confronted with the footage.
Qadri further argued that the disclosure statement made before the Executive Magistrate had been corroborated by the statements of prosecution witnesses, particularly PWs 5, 31 and 34. He also pointed out that the CCTV footage had been seized as part of the chargesheet and that a Railway Protection Force official, listed as PW 38, was yet to depose regarding the footage.
After examining the rival submissions and the trial court record, the High Court held that the restrictions under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA were attracted.
The bench observed that the provision prohibits the release on bail of an accused facing charges under Chapters IV and VI of the Act if the court, upon examining the case diary or chargesheet, finds reasonable grounds to believe that the accusations are prima facie true.
Explaining the scope of the provision, the court observed that the expression “prima facie true” means something more than mere suspicion or conjecture but less than proof.
It further clarified that a court deciding a bail application is not required to conduct a preliminary trial or determine the guilt or innocence of the accused, which can only be decided at the conclusion of the trial.
The bench also relied upon the Supreme Court’s judgment in Jalaluddin Khan versus Union of India, decided on August 13, 2024, which dealt with the interpretation of Section 43D(5) of the UAPA.
Referring to the evidence of PWs 5, 31 and 34, the High Court said it had reason to believe at this stage of the trial that there were reasonable grounds for considering the accusations against Bhat prima facie true.
On the argument of prolonged incarceration, the court acknowledged that an accused has a fundamental right to a speedy trial under Article 21 of the Constitution. However, it said a balance had to be maintained between the interests of the State and society and those of an individual accused.
The bench also noted that the offence under Section 18 of the UAPA carries punishment extending to life imprisonment. It observed that although Bhat had remained in detention for more than four and a half years, he had not completed even one-half or two-thirds of the maximum punishment to claim entitlement to bail under Section 479 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
Finding no illegality in the trial court’s order, the High Court concluded that the appeal lacked merit and dismissed it.
However, the bench clarified that its observations were limited to the consideration of the bail appeal and should not be construed as prejudging the merits of the case, which would be decided at the conclusion of the trial.
The court also requested the trial court to expedite proceedings in the main case.















