SRINAGAR: The Jammu Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has modified a Jammu and Kashmir Special Tribunal order concerning a proposed commercial building on land belonging to a mosque in Kupwara, ruling that failure by municipal authorities to decide the matter within the stipulated 30 days cannot automatically lead to cancellation of the order keeping the building permission in abeyance.
The court, however, upheld the Tribunal’s direction requiring the municipal authorities to take a final decision on the matter within 30 days, making it clear that the deadline would begin afresh from November 11, the date of the High Court order.
Justice Sanjay Dhar passed the directions while disposing of a writ petition filed by inhabitants of Syedabad Kupwara, who had challenged the Special Tribunal’s order dated September 8, 2025.
The petitioners had specifically objected to the Tribunal’s direction that if the municipal authorities failed to decide the matter within 30 days, the order keeping the building permission in abeyance would be deemed cancelled, allowing respondent No. 6 to proceed with construction.
Examining the matter, the High Court observed that the municipal authorities’ order dated October 8, 2022, keeping the building permission in abeyance, was a temporary measure and could not remain in force indefinitely.
“The validity of order dated 08.10.2022 can be stretched only up to the time the Municipal Authorities take a decision on the objections received relating to grant of building permission in favour of respondent No.6,” the court observed.
The court held that the Tribunal had rightly directed the municipal authorities to decide the issue within 30 days, as the original order keeping the building permission in abeyance had been issued to enable consideration of complaints and representations against the proposed construction.
However, Justice Dhar found that the provision allowing automatic cancellation of the order in the event of administrative delay required modification to address the petitioners’ concerns.
“Default on the part of the Municipal Authorities to decide the fate of order dated 08.10.2022, whereby building permission of respondent No.6 has been kept in abeyance, shall not lead to automatic cancellation of said order,” the court directed.
The court further clarified that both the petitioners and respondent No. 6 would be entitled to submit additional representations and produce documents before the municipal authorities, which would have to be considered while taking the final decision.
The dispute has a history of litigation between the inhabitants of Syedabad and respondent No. 6 over the proposed construction of a commercial building on land belonging to a mosque at Mouza Kupwara.
According to the court order, the municipal authorities had granted building permission in favour of respondent No. 6 through an order dated August 22, 2022. The inhabitants subsequently challenged the permission before the Jammu and Kashmir Special Tribunal, Srinagar, through a revision petition, which was dismissed on October 20, 2022.
Thereafter, the municipal authorities issued another order on October 8, 2022, keeping the building permission in abeyance following complaints and representations from the petitioners and other persons objecting to the proposed construction.
Respondent No. 6 subsequently challenged the municipal authorities’ decision before the Special Tribunal, which passed the order on September 8, 2025. While directing the authorities to take a final decision within 30 days, the Tribunal had provided that failure to do so would result in the order keeping the building permission in abeyance being deemed cancelled.
Aggrieved by this provision, the inhabitants approached the High Court through the present writ petition, WP(C) No. 2705/2025.
Advocates Shafqat Nazir and Heena Baqal appeared for the petitioners, while Senior Advocate Faisal Qadiri, assisted by Advocate Noman, represented the respondents. Advocates Sheikh Manzoor, Waseem Gul and Ilyas Laway also appeared in the matter.
Disposing of the writ petition along with the connected applications, the High Court directed the municipal authorities to decide the issue within the period stipulated by the Tribunal, commencing from November 11, 2026.
The order was pronounced on November 11, 2026.













