**
Monday, November 16, 2026
spot_img

Are We Becoming More Informed but Less Wise?

   

by Shabeer Ahmad Lone

Follow Us OnG-News | Whatsapp

This essay argues that reclaiming depth requires critical thought, ethical action, meaningful relationships, inclusive education, responsible technology and ecological care to reconnect knowledge with wisdom and progress with human flourishing.

Smartphones have replaced a lot of things – radio, tape-recorder, TV, telephone, calculator, thermometer, camera, calendar, book, wristwatch and to a large extent bank and the wallet. It is a window to information as newspapers have been completely replaced. The traditional matchmaker is on the margins now.

Baazeecha-e-atfaal hai duniya mere aage
Hota hai shab-o-roz tamaasha mere aage
— Ghalib

Zaahir ki aankh se na tamaasha kare koi
Ho dekhna to deedah-e-dil waa kare koi
— Iqbal

Superficiality is sustained by power, propaganda, consumerism, psychological conditioning and historical amnesia. Resisting it requires critical reasoning, intellectual humility, democratic dialogue, social justice, gender equality, cultural dignity and ecological responsibility. It demands freedom from ideological conformity, respect for marginalised knowledge, meaningful relationships and an awareness of mortality. Art, literature and spirituality deepen human understanding when accompanied by sincerity, compassion and ethical action. Ultimately, depth unites intellectual discernment, moral integrity, emotional maturity, spiritual awareness and social responsibility, reconciling knowledge with wisdom, conviction with conduct and progress with human flourishing.

We inhabit an age of unprecedented information, technological advancement and global connectivity. Yet a fundamental question persists: has the expansion of knowledge deepened our wisdom, understanding and moral consciousness? Are we becoming more informed but not necessarily wiser, more connected but not necessarily closer, and more accomplished but not necessarily fulfilled?

This is the paradox of our time: information without sufficient understanding, communication without meaningful connection, and material progress without corresponding moral advancement.

Superficiality is the preference for appearance over substance, information over understanding, recognition over contribution and immediate gratification over enduring fulfilment. It is not merely an individual weakness; it can permeate education, politics, religion, technology, institutions and entire civilisations. Its greatest danger lies in its ability to imitate depth.

Resisting superficiality is neither a rejection of modernity nor a romanticisation of the past. It is a movement from appearance to reality, passive reception to critical inquiry, self-display to responsibility, and external achievement to human flourishing.

Chrar-i-Sharief Shrine (KL Image by Shuaib Wani)
Chrar-i-Sharief Shrine (KL Image by Shuaib Wani)

Philosophical Foundations

The philosophical tradition begins with self-examination. Socrates challenged unexamined assumptions; Plato’s allegory of the cave exposed the distance between appearance and reality; Aristotle connected human flourishing with virtue, reason and practical wisdom. Confucius emphasised humane relationships, Laozi simplicity, Buddhist thought freedom from craving, and Nāgārjuna the critique of fixed conceptual attachments. The Upanishads explored self-knowledge, while the Bhagavad Gita examined disciplined action and detachment.

The Qur’an invites tadabbur, tafakkur and ta’aqqul, contemplation, reflection and reason. Its depiction of a good word as a rooted tree bearing fruit (14:24–25) connects conviction with beneficial action. Its call to use the faculties of understanding (7:179), reflect upon creation (3:190–191), seek wisdom (2:269), listen attentively (39:18) and verify information (17:36) establishes an ethic of intellectual responsibility.

Islamic thought deepens this inquiry through Al-Ghazali’s emphasis on inward sincerity, Ibn Rushd’s defence of reason, Ibn Arabi’s metaphysics and Rumi’s vision of love and transformation. Rabia al-Adawiyya represents selfless devotion; Kabir challenges religious pretension; and the Guru Granth Sahib, including the poetry of Sheikh Farid, connects remembrance with honest labour and human dignity. Christian contemplatives such as Meister Eckhart, Julian of Norwich and Teresa of Ávila likewise explore inward transformation. These traditions offer meaningful encounters without implying doctrinal equivalence.

Modern philosophy adds further dimensions: Kant’s intellectual autonomy, Kierkegaard’s inward commitment, Nietzsche’s critique of inherited values, Camus’s confrontation with absurdity, and Hannah Arendt’s warning against thoughtlessness. Buber emphasises genuine encounter, Levinas ethical responsibility, and Popper critical scrutiny. Together, they affirm that depth requires independent judgement, humility and openness to correction.

The Quran recitation is all right but understanding it is mandatory

Knowledge Justice

The pursuit of depth must also confront unequal access to knowledge and authority. Wollstonecraft challenged women’s educational exclusion; Woolf examined intellectual independence; and Beauvoir exposed gendered inequality. bell hooks connected education with liberation, while Audre Lorde explored difference and power. Miranda Fricker, Sandra Harding and Kristie Dotson demonstrated how prejudice, exclusion and silencing shape knowledge. Nussbaum’s capabilities approach and Amartya Sen’s conception of development as freedom further insist that progress must expand human dignity, agency and opportunity.

Literature deepens moral imagination. Shakespeare explores ambition and moral blindness; Dostoevsky, conscience; Tolstoy, mortality; Toni Morrison, memory and injustice; Chinua Achebe, cultural dignity; and Mahmoud Darwish, exile and belonging. Ghalib explores uncertainty, Iqbal selfhood, Faiz justice and human suffering, and Tagore creativity, education and humanism. Literature, at its best, enables us to encounter lives beyond our own.

Digital Challenges

Contemporary technology makes the recovery of depth particularly urgent. Digital platforms expand access and expression, yet their incentives may reward speed, novelty and provocation over accuracy and reflection. UNESCO’s 2023 report, Technology in Education: A Tool on Whose Terms?, raises an essential question: does technology serve education, or does it determine its purposes? Artificial intelligence offers powerful opportunities, but factual errors, fabricated references and inherited biases demand verification and human judgement.

Education must therefore transcend the mere transmission of information. Dewey understood learning as experiential and democratic; Freire challenged passive instruction; and Tagore advocated creativity and freedom. UNESCO’s 2021 report, Reimagining Our Futures Together, calls for education grounded in justice, diversity and solidarity. Genuine education cultivates curiosity, critical reasoning, creativity and ethical judgement—not merely qualifications.

Human Connections

The same principle applies to relationships. Buber’s philosophy of encounter and Levinas’s ethics of responsibility remind us that human beings must never be reduced to instruments. The WHO’s 2025 report on social connection underscores the importance of meaningful belonging. Connection depends not on the number of contacts we maintain, but on presence, listening, reciprocity and care.

Ecological responsibility exposes the limitations of superficial progress. UNEP’s Global Resources Outlook 2024 documents the consequences of resource extraction for climate, biodiversity and pollution. Wangari Maathai connected ecological restoration with women’s participation, while Elinor Ostrom demonstrated the possibilities of community-based resource governance. Indigenous knowledge also offers insights into stewardship and interdependence, deserving respect without romanticisation.

A 1902 photograph of Dargah Hazratbal in Srinagar.

Lives of Service

Lives devoted to service demonstrate how conviction becomes action. Abdul Sattar Edhi embodied humanitarian compassion; A. P. J. Abdul Kalam connected science with education and public welfare; Nelson Mandela exemplified the struggle for justice and reconciliation; and Malala Yousafzai advocates educational rights. Viktor Frankl explored the search for meaning under adversity. Their legacies remind us that meaningful change requires commitment, service and responsibility.

Yet the critique of superficiality must examine itself. Intellectualism can become elitism, spirituality escapism, tradition exclusion and criticism cynicism. Authenticity itself can become a performance. Depth is not obscurity, simplicity is not ignorance, and popularity is not proof of worthlessness. What matters is whether ideas withstand scrutiny and contribute to human flourishing.

Practical Commitments

Reclaiming depth requires action at five interconnected levels: personal, through self-examination and integrity; intellectual, through critical inquiry and verification; institutional, through accountability and inclusive education; technological, through intentional use and human oversight; and civilisational, through justice, ecological responsibility and solidarity.

These commitments begin with ordinary practices: reading beyond headlines, consulting original sources, verifying claims, listening attentively, reflecting before reacting and remaining open to correction. The teacher who awakens curiosity, the researcher who acknowledges limitations, the journalist who verifies information, the public servant who acts honestly, the farmer who cares for the soil and the neighbour who responds to suffering all embody depth.

Shabeer Ahmad Lone

Reclaiming depth is not a withdrawal from contemporary life, but a more responsible participation in it. It is philosophical in its pursuit of truth, ethical in its demand for integrity, spiritual in its concern with inward transformation, literary in its respect for imagination, feminist in its challenge to exclusion, ecological in its recognition of interdependence and civilisational in its commitment to shared human flourishing.

Most fundamentally, a civilisation cannot be judged by technological sophistication, economic prosperity or cultural display alone, but by how it educates its young, treats its vulnerable, honours women’s dignity, protects nature, embraces difference and distributes opportunity justly. Its true progress lies not merely in knowing more, possessing more or attracting attention, but in understanding deeply, judging wisely and contributing meaningfully.

A civilisation’s depth is measured not by the abundance of its achievements, but by the wisdom of its understanding, the justice of its actions and the humanity of its relationships. Its greatest legacy is not what it accumulates, but the dignity it nurtures and the better world it leaves behind.

(The author is an educator, researcher and writer. Ideas are personal.)

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here