**
Monday, November 16, 2026
spot_img

Jammu Kashmir High Court Upholds 14-Year Jail Term for Man Convicted of Raping 8-Year-Old Niece

   

SRINAGAR: The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has upheld the conviction and 14-year rigorous imprisonment awarded to a man from Udhampur for raping his eight-year-old niece, dismissing his appeal against the trial court’s judgment and holding that the child’s testimony was reliable and sufficiently supported by medical evidence.

Follow Us OnG-News | Whatsapp

A Division Bench of Justice Shahzad Azeem and Justice Sanjay Dhar, in a judgment pronounced on November 13, 2026, dismissed the appeal filed by Sanjay Kumar alias Sanju, observing that the prosecution had established his guilt beyond reasonable doubt and that there was no justification to interfere with the conviction or sentence.

The appellant had challenged the judgment of conviction dated April 16, 2024, and the order of sentence dated April 25, 2024, passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Udhampur. He had been convicted under Sections 376 and 342 of the Ranbir Penal Code (RPC) and sentenced to 14 years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1 lakh for rape, besides one year’s imprisonment for wrongful confinement.

The appeal, CrlA(D) No. 16/2024, was heard by the Division Bench after being filed through the appellant’s 75-year-old mother, Taro Devi. Senior Advocate Surinder Kour, assisted by Advocate Manpreet Kour, represented the appellant, while Senior Advocate Raman Sharma, assisted by Advocates Kartikay Sharma and Saliqa Sheikh, appeared for the respondents.

The case originated from an incident reported on April 23, 2017, when the victim, then aged eight, had gone to the appellant’s house in the neighbourhood to play hide-and-seek with the children of the family. According to the prosecution, the accused, who was her paternal uncle, took her into a makeshift room in the house, shut the door, removed her lower garments and sexually assaulted her.

The child returned home crying, with blood-stained clothes. The prosecution alleged that the accused followed her and poured two to three jugs of water over her, claiming that she was feeling hot. When her mother, Neelam Devi, questioned her about the bleeding, the child narrated the incident to her.

Her mother subsequently informed her husband, Ramesh Kumar, following which neighbours were called and the child was taken to Police Station Rehmbal. A written complaint was submitted at around 4.25 pm, leading to the registration of FIR No. 50/2017 under Sections 376 and 342 RPC. She was subsequently taken to District Hospital, Udhampur, for medical examination and treatment, where two stitches were reportedly administered.

During the investigation, the police seized the child’s blood-stained clothes, blood samples, hair samples, blood-stained soil and plain soil. After completion of the investigation, a challan was presented before the court, and the accused was put on trial.

The trial court had relied primarily on the testimony of the child, her immediate disclosure to her mother, the accounts of her parents and the medical evidence. It found her statement consistent and trustworthy, holding that it had remained intact despite detailed cross-examination.

Challenging the conviction, the appellant’s counsel argued that the prosecution had failed to establish the charges beyond reasonable doubt and that the trial court had misread and misappreciated the evidence.

The defence alleged that the case was fabricated because of a land dispute between the two families. It also questioned the delay in recording the statements of the prosecutrix and her parents during the investigation, pointing out that the child’s statement was recorded after 14 days of the incident, while those of her parents were recorded after 23 to 24 days.

The counsel further highlighted alleged inconsistencies in the accounts of witnesses regarding who first reached the victim’s house after the incident and who accompanied her to the police station and hospital. It was also argued that despite the child’s claim of raising an alarm, nobody from the accused’s household or the neighbourhood had heard her cries.

Questioning the medical evidence, the defence submitted that the doctor had acknowledged that a torn hymen could result from activities such as playing or cycling, while a vaginal tear could also occur due to accidental contact with a wooden log or metal rod. The absence of spermatozoa and external injuries was also cited to challenge the prosecution’s version.

The appellant’s counsel maintained that the conviction rested on the solitary and allegedly uncorroborated testimony of the child, which, according to the defence, was insufficient to sustain the charges.

Opposing the appeal, Senior Advocate Raman Sharma submitted that the child’s testimony was of sterling quality and was duly corroborated by medical evidence. He argued that minor discrepancies in the statements of witnesses and the delay in recording their statements by the investigating officers could not undermine an otherwise credible prosecution case.

After examining the evidence, the Division Bench found that the child’s account was consistent on the essential aspects of the incident and that she had withstood detailed cross-examination.

The court noted that the child had clearly described how the accused took her into a room, closed the door, removed her clothes and sexually assaulted her, following which she returned home crying and bleeding. It also took note of her account that the accused followed her and poured water over her.

The Bench observed that her testimony was supported by her mother’s account of finding her crying with blood-stained clothes and the accused following her. Her father also corroborated the immediate disclosure and subsequent steps taken by the family, while Ajay Kumar, who drove them to the police station and hospital, supported the sequence of events.

Medical evidence also played a significant role in the court’s assessment. Dr Sanjay Verma, a gynaecologist who examined the child at around 6 pm on the day of the incident, found that her posterior fourchette and hymen were torn. He also recorded a first-degree tear in the vaginal wall, which required stitching, along with substantial vaginal bleeding.

The doctor, relying on the histopathological examination of the vaginal smear and clinical findings, opined that the child had experienced sexual intercourse within 12 hours of the examination.

The Bench held that the medical findings were consistent with the child’s account of penetration and resulting injuries, providing strong corroboration to her testimony.

Dealing with the objection regarding the delay in recording statements, the court noted that the investigating officers had explained the circumstances. Inspector Vishal Manhas stated that he had been occupied with the arrest of the accused and other investigative steps, while another investigating officer, Sanjay Raina, cited his other official duties. A subsequent investigating officer, Sohan Singh, stated that the earlier officers had not recorded the statements and that the case file indicated that the child was not fit to make a statement at the relevant time.

The Bench accepted the explanations, observing that the delay had been properly accounted for and did not, by itself, cast doubt on the prosecution’s case.

The court also rejected the defence argument that the incident was the result of a land dispute, noting that the child had specifically denied the existence of such a dispute and the allegation that her parents had tutored her to make a false statement.

Emphasising the evidentiary value of a child victim’s testimony in sexual assault cases, the Bench reiterated that a conviction can be based on the sole testimony of a prosecutrix if it is found reliable and trustworthy.

Referring to the Supreme Court’s judgment in Rai Sandeep alias Deepu vs State (NCT of Delhi), the High Court noted that corroboration is not a requirement of law but a matter of prudence, and that the testimony of a sexual assault victim can independently sustain a conviction if it inspires confidence.

The Bench also relied on the Supreme Court’s observations in State of Himachal Pradesh vs Sanjay Kumar alias Sunny, a case involving the rape of a nine-year-old girl by her uncle, and State of Madhya Pradesh vs Balveer Singh, while assessing the credibility of child witnesses and the impact of minor inconsistencies in their statements.

In its judgment, the court observed: “The statement of the prosecutrix is the foundation of the prosecution case in offences of sexual assault.”

It further held that a victim of sexual assault is not an accomplice and that her evidence, particularly when she is a child, deserves considerable weight.

Concluding its assessment, the Division Bench observed that the child’s testimony was coherent, natural and consistent, and that her account regarding the identity of the accused, the place and manner of assault, the immediate aftermath and subsequent disclosure was supported by the evidence of her parents, the accompanying witness and contemporaneous medical findings.

“The minor discrepancies and the delay in formal recordings of statements have been satisfactorily explained and do not touch the core of the prosecution case,” the court held.

Finding that the prosecution had established the charges under Sections 376 and 342 RPC beyond reasonable doubt, the Bench concluded that the conviction and sentence were fully justified.

“Accordingly, the appeal is found to be without merit and is dismissed. Judgement of conviction and order of sentence passed by the trial court are affirmed,” the court ordered.

The Bench directed that a copy of the judgment, along with the case record, be sent to the trial court forthwith for information and further follow-up.

The judgment was authored by Justice Shahzad Azeem and concurred with by Justice Sanjay Dhar. It was reserved on October 30, 2026, and pronounced on November 13, 2026.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here