**
Friday, November 20, 2026
spot_img

Kashmir Study Finds Rheumatoid Arthritis Taking a Heavy Toll on Women’s Family

   

A University of Kashmir study finds that rheumatoid arthritis, compounded by gender discrimination, healthcare barriers and social stigma, deprives Kashmiri women of livelihoods, family roles, social participation and decision-making power.

Follow Us OnG-News | Whatsapp
Rheumatoid Arthritis (Representational Picture from Creative Commons)

SRINAGAR: For women living with rheumatoid arthritis in Kashmir, chronic pain is not confined to swollen joints and restricted movement. It can mean losing the ability to cook for the family, look after children, work in fields, maintain marital relationships and participate in social and religious customs.

A new study by researchers from the University of Kashmir has found that rheumatoid arthritis (RA), compounded by entrenched gender expectations, limited access to specialised healthcare and social stigma, is gradually pushing women into greater dependence, isolation and exclusion from household decision-making.

Published in Dialogues in Health, the study, Gendered Role Disruption in Women with Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Phenomenological Study in Kashmir, draws on interviews with 15 women aged between 21 and 67 who had been diagnosed with the disease for at least a year.

The researchers found that the consequences of the disease extended well beyond its physical symptoms, affecting women’s identities and their standing within families and communities. The study was conducted by Zakir Hussain Gadda, Mohmad Saleem Jahangir and Aneesa Shafi of the Department of Sociology, University of Kashmir.

Beyond The Disease

Rheumatoid arthritis is a chronic autoimmune condition in which the immune system attacks the joints, causing inflammation, pain, stiffness and, in some cases, progressive disability. Although the condition cannot be cured, timely diagnosis and treatment can help control symptoms and prevent further joint damage. Women are considerably more likely than men to develop the disease.

The researchers argue that for women in Kashmir, the burden of RA is intensified by social expectations that place much of the responsibility for domestic work, childcare and family care on them. “When women are unable to perform these roles, they often experience feelings of inadequacy, guilt, and diminished self-worth,” the study observes.

Most participants had been diagnosed during their productive years, when family and social expectations placed considerable demands on their physical abilities.

Of the 15 women interviewed, 12 identified themselves as housewives, two were PhD scholars and one was a student. Seven were illiterate, while household incomes ranged from Rs 6,000 to Rs 2 lakh a month.

Healthcare Barriers

The study identifies patriarchal household structures and gaps in healthcare access as important factors worsening the experiences of women with RA.

According to the researchers, women in some households must seek permission from male family members or be accompanied by a mehram (male guardian) to access healthcare. Women’s health concerns are also sometimes dismissed as exaggeration or as excuses to avoid household and agricultural responsibilities. In economically disadvantaged families, treatment for male members may receive priority, while women postpone medical attention to meet the needs of their children. Access to specialised treatment presents another challenge, particularly for women living in rural areas who must travel to urban centres for consultations.

The researchers also point to the limitations of Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PM-JAY), which provides health coverage of up to Rs 5 lakh per eligible family annually, arguing that its emphasis on hospitalisation does not adequately address the long-term outpatient medication and transport costs faced by people with RA. The paper cites earlier research indicating that patients frequently resort to self-medication and purchasing medicines from local medical shops, delaying proper diagnosis and treatment.

Citing a study conducted at the Sher-i-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences (SKIMS), the researchers note that RA was identified in 615 of 1,738 patients attending its rheumatology department. Women accounted for 76.7 per cent of those diagnosed. The authors caution that hospital-based figures may not reflect the actual burden, as people with milder symptoms often do not seek specialised care.

Household Burden

One of the most significant findings concerns the disruption of domestic responsibilities. Women interviewed for the study described how joint pain, stiffness and fatigue had made everyday activities such as cooking, cleaning, washing clothes, bending and carrying household items increasingly difficult.

One participant said that cooking, cleaning and laundry had become nearly impossible, leaving her feeling incapable, sad and guilty. For some, the inability to perform domestic work had altered their relationships with other family members. One woman recalled that her daughter’s family had previously taken her along to Jammu during winters to help with household chores. However, after her physical condition deteriorated, they stopped taking her because she was no longer able to contribute to the work.

Another participant said her daughter-in-law had expressed regret over marrying her son, claiming she would not have agreed to the marriage had she known about the woman’s illness. The disease also transferred domestic responsibilities to other family members, particularly daughters.

One participant said her daughter frequently missed university classes to manage household work. Another described how one of her daughters had left school to care for her. The women said such changes left them feeling guilty about disrupting their children’s education and daily lives.

Marital Strain

The study also documents how RA affects marital relationships, intimacy and women’s reproductive lives. Almost all married participants described difficulties maintaining sexual relationships because of pain, fatigue, restricted movement and other physical complications associated with the disease.

The researchers note that expectations surrounding marital intimacy and a woman’s perceived responsibilities towards her husband can intensify the emotional burden. One participant said her religious understanding of marriage made her feel obligated to remain available to her husband, but her illness frequently prevented her from meeting his expectations. Another woman said the smell of medicinal ointments bothered her husband and that her inability to maintain personal hygiene as before had affected their relationship.

Women with younger husbands expressed fears of rejection or abandonment. Some participants who had been diagnosed during their reproductive years were also reluctant to consider pregnancy because of their physical limitations and uncertainty about their ability to manage childbirth and childcare.

The study found that these concerns were rarely discussed with healthcare professionals. One participant said discussing sexual life with an outsider, particularly a male doctor, was considered taboo. She added that none of the doctors treating her had asked how RA affected her reproductive or sexual life.

The researchers argue that the absence of such conversations leaves an important dimension of women’s health unaddressed.

Motherhood Affected

The inability to perform childcare responsibilities emerged as another major source of distress. Participants described difficulties lifting children, preparing meals, dressing them, taking them to school and attending school functions. One mother said she often could not prepare breakfast because of pain, resulting in her children going to school hungry. Another said she could no longer trim her children’s nails because she could not hold a nail cutter properly. Her children subsequently faced embarrassment at school.

A participant diagnosed when her children were still in primary school said her limited mobility affected their vaccinations and routine medical check-ups. “I would vent my anger on them,” she said, describing herself as a failed mother.

The difficulties extended to grandmothers; several of whom said they could no longer look after grandchildren as they once did. One participant who had previously cared for three children at a time said she could no longer lift even one child without assistance.

The researchers also document the disruption of traditional Kashmiri family customs. One participant, who was unable to perform Mohar Tulen, a ritual involving the lifting of a daughter-in-law’s veil during her first visit, had to let her daughter perform the custom instead. The study notes that some relatives considered this inappropriate and subsequently associated difficulties in the couple’s life with her inability to perform the ritual.

Livelihood Lost

For several women, the disease also meant losing their ability to earn an income. Before developing RA, some participants contributed to household finances through agricultural work, maintaining livestock, selling milk, working in orchards and participating in saffron cultivation.

As their mobility declined, many were forced to abandon these activities, increasing their financial dependence on family members. One participant who had previously collected leftover saffron petals during the harvest season and earned a substantial amount said she now depended entirely on her family for survival.

Another said she could no longer earn and had become financially dependent on relatives. The cost of treatment added to the strain. One family reportedly stopped construction of its house to meet medical expenses.

In another case, an only son moved into a separate house, citing the financial burden of his mother’s treatment. Her unmarried daughters subsequently took responsibility for looking after her and her husband.

Women employed outside their homes also described discrimination and difficulties maintaining their jobs. One participant working in the private sector concealed her illness from colleagues but eventually quit after repeated absences raised suspicions. Another woman with a master’s degree said she was rejected for a private-school teaching position because the employer wanted someone physically fit.

Social Isolation

The researchers found that RA had also restricted women’s participation in social and community life. Participants described being unable to attend weddings, funerals, festivals, family gatherings and other important occasions because of pain and mobility limitations. Some avoided visiting relatives because they feared becoming a burden on their hosts, who might have to arrange special seating or other facilities.

One participant said missing her niece’s wedding led to a breakdown in relations with her sister’s family. Another said relatives had labelled her disabled and a glutton because of the way she had to sit while eating, making her reluctant to attend social gatherings.

The inability to participate in traditional exchanges of gifts and visits also affected their sense of belonging. Although some women maintained contact through telephone calls, they said this could not replace physical interaction.

The study found that social withdrawal often resulted in loneliness, anxiety and a diminished sense of self-worth.

Losing A Voice

The researchers identify the loss of decision-making power as another major consequence of the disease. As women became increasingly dependent on family members, some were excluded from decisions concerning household finances, children’s upbringing, reproductive choices and everyday family affairs.

One participant said her sisters-in-law had dissolved the joint family arrangement to exclude her and subsequently taken control of household decisions. Another woman said she faced domestic violence after deciding against another pregnancy because of her illness, despite her husband’s opposition to the decision.

A 65-year-old widow described how her inability to travel to prospective grooms’ homes or consult trusted people had affected her efforts to arrange marriages for her two daughters.

In some cases, the consequences extended to property and financial security.  One couple reportedly transferred their property to a relative in exchange for lifelong care. However, the woman said the arrangement had left them without control over their own lives. “Now everything is dictated by them,” she said. “We are like mere beggars, confined in a solitary room.”

Another bedridden participant said her sisters-in-law had taken decisions about her children’s clothing, food and social interactions, while discouraging the children from spending time with her.

Family Support

Despite the accounts of exclusion and dependence, the study also found that supportive family relationships helped some women cope with the disease. Husbands who shared domestic responsibilities, children who assisted with daily activities and relatives who accommodated physical limitations helped women maintain a degree of independence.

Some participants adapted by performing household tasks while seated, using assistive devices, engaging in prayer and reading, and maintaining contact with relatives. One woman said she had found comfort in prayer, reading the Quran, cooking while seated and completing smaller household activities. Others spoke about following medical advice, light exercise and home remedies alongside medication.

The researchers, however, stress that individual coping mechanisms cannot substitute for adequate medical care and social support.

Policy Concerns

The authors describe the experiences documented in the study as a social justice concern, arguing that the impact of RA on women cannot be addressed through medical treatment alone. They recommend involving family members in treatment and rehabilitation to improve understanding of the disease and reduce the stigma associated with disability.

The study also calls for educational workshops at family and village levels, greater awareness among healthcare professionals about the psychological and sexual consequences of RA, and culturally sensitive spaces where women can discuss issues surrounding intimacy and reproductive health.

The authors further urge policymakers and voluntary organisations to address the loss of livelihoods among women with chronic illnesses and introduce social protection measures that account for treatment expenses and lost income.

They argue that healthcare interventions must recognise the social and economic conditions in which women experience chronic illness. The researchers acknowledge that the study involved only 15 Kashmiri-speaking Muslim women and therefore cannot represent the experiences of all women across Jammu and Kashmir. They call for larger studies involving women from different religious, ethnic and socioeconomic backgrounds.

For the women interviewed, however, the findings point to a reality in which chronic illness can gradually reshape almost every aspect of life, from earning a livelihood and raising children to maintaining relationships and exercising control over personal decisions.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here