Government’s New Idea Can Get GMC De-Recognized

by Masood Hussain

SRINAGAR: The state-run Medical College in Srinagar may be again pushed to the edge as the authorities want some of the existing faculties to man the about-to-start new medical colleges across the state. If it happens, insiders said, it will be a deadly blow to the college that is already facing a serious crisis on faculty front.

GMC Srinagar

The policymakers in the civil secretariat want 13 teaching positions to be shifted out of GMC on “lateral entry” basis. From GMC, Jammu, seven teaching positions will also follow the suit. Both the colleges are in stress and have voiced their anger against the order that will destabilise both the institutions.

The heads of the twin colleges got the communication from the Health and Medical Education department on December 13, last year when they were asked to offer comments on the select list of doctors who are being considered “for transfer and adjustment y lateral entry in the five newly established Medical Colleges of the state”. The communication sought an impact assessment in case these faculty positions are shifted.

Responding to the communication on December 26, 2018, Dr Sunanda Raina, who heads the GMC Jammu, said the idea was not in the interest of either of the two institutions.  She had enough grounds to support her decision.

“These faculty members in Annexure A & B are working after the selection by the Public Service Commission J&K in respective Govt. Medical Colleges permanently by virtue of various Government Orders,” her communication said. “In all regards, their heads are counted by Medical Council of India in their respective Medical Colleges with regard to the permanent faculty positions they are holding.”

The letter insisted that the MCI will not count any such head as posted on lateral entry basis in both the institutions, as they are swapped as proposed. “This is likely to lead to huge faculty deficiency in various cadres not only at GMC, Srinagar but also in GMC Jammu as well and any faculty deficiency by any such action shall pose the threat of de-recognition of both these institutions,” the letter, addressed to the Principal Secretary Health and Medical Education department reads.

Besides, she has said that “posting of any such doctors on lateral entry basis in GMC Jammu/Srinagar or in New Medical Colleges shall also create a conflict of interest and seniority between the Faculty Members and thus shall invite litigations.” The PSC and MCI, it adds, do not permit the lateral entry. “It will set wrong precedence amongst the Faculty members of both the institutions,” it adds.

GMC, Srinagar, it may be recalled here, has fought odds to prevent de-recognition of the MCI because it had a huge vacancy in the faculty set up both in the GMC and the super-speciality hospital. “Every single faculty member that has been identified for transfer is linked to at least three post-graduation,” one senior faculty in GMC, Srinagar, told Kashmir Life. “So, if at all, it happens, we are looking a crippling disruption at 40 positions.”

The dozen doctors whom the Medical Education department has identified for lateral entry include Associated Professor anaesthesiology Dr Sanjay Kalrotra, Associate Prof Pharmacology Vineeta Sawhney, medicine lecturer Dr Vinod Mitla, Associate Professor medicine Dr Badri Nath Bhogal, lecturer anaesthesiology Dr Rubeena Nazir, biochemistry lecturer Dr Ashok Bhagat, paediatrics Associate Professor Dr Virendra Bhagat to the upcoming GMC in Kathua.

Prof Ghulam Ali Shah (anaesthesiology) and Assistant Professor Paediatrics Javaid Iqbal have been identified for the GMC Rajouri. While medicine Assistant Professor Dr Mohammad Ashraf has been identified for lateral entry for GMC, Anantnag, two Assistant Professors in Surgery – Dr Kulwant Singh and Dr M R Atri have been identified to go for lateral entry in the GMC Jammu.

Interestingly, four of them – Mitla, Rubeena, Javaid and Baghat are borne on the GMC Srinagar establishment but are serving the GMC Jammu for one or the other reason.

Informed sources told Kashmir Life that GMC Srinagar is still facing a sort of crisis as far as its faculty position is concerned. It has three institutions to manage: the GMC, the Dental College and the Super-Speciality Hospital. With 460 positions for GMC, 27 for GDC and 72 for the Super Speciality Hospital, the entire health triangle in Srinagar requires a total of 559 positions.

But given the crisis it is facing, it has more than half the positions vacant. These include 242 positions in the GMC, and 60 in Super Speciality hospital which makes a total of 302 vacancies.

Off late, the hospital has been running the show with the in-charge system and on academic arrangement basis. Right now, on a substantive basis, the GMC Srinagar has only 233 positions in place – 228 in GMC and five in Super Speciality Hospital.

Right now, there are a total of 24 positions which are managed on an in-charge basis. Besides, there are 56 other positions which are being managed on academic arrangement basis. If the positions being managed on academic arrangement basis are added to the vacant faculty list, it will show a much serious crisis in the GMC.

“In such a situation, there is a serious tension if the plans of the policy-makers are implemented,” one senior doctor said. “It can push the institution backwards.”

Another senior doctor said that depletion of the faculty is a crisis that the GMC is already facing and if the listed doctors are permitted to go, it will add to the crisis. “The GMC should have no problem in issuing NOC to some of the doctors who are retiring this year if they choose to build the new colleges,” the senior doctor said. “But in most of the cases, there is no possibility of issuing a NOC because it will get us de-recognition. For every professor we permit the transfer, we will be losing three PG seats. How can we afford it?”

Insiders in the GMC said they can help the government by relieving ten doctors who are deputed by the Director of Health Services against teaching positions. “They have been teaching at the GMC for more than a decade and have enough of capacity and knowledge of working at a teaching hospital that they can help the newer college take off,” one senior insider in the GMC Srinagar said. “We are already facing the crisis because some doctors from Jammu who were appointed by the PSC for GMC Jammu have used different routes to serve at Jammu which is unfortunate.” These include the only CVT surgeon that PSC had appointed to the GMC, Srinagar.

Both the heads of the GMCs have responded in negative. What the policymakers in the civil secretariat will now be doing is immediately not known. Interestingly, most of the new medical colleges are still not having even the buildings. How wise is the wisdom than existing colleges start getting disrupted for the college that will take some more time?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here