**
Monday, November 16, 2026
spot_img

Kashmir’s Gig Workers Face Unstable Earnings, Algorithmic Control and Lack of Social Security, Study Finds

   

A new study examining the changing nature of employment in Kashmir has found that gig workers, including delivery personnel, taxi drivers, online freelancers and private tutors, are increasingly dependent on irregular platform-based work while remaining without basic employment protections. The research highlights unstable incomes, opaque payment systems and the absence of health benefits and paid leave, even as workers value the flexibility these jobs offer.

Follow Us OnG-News | Whatsapp
Courier boys in Srinagar in a group photograph

SRINAGAR: A new research study has highlighted the growing dependence of young people and informal workers in Kashmir on the gig economy, warning that the flexibility offered by platform-based employment comes at the cost of income security, social protection and control over working conditions.

Published in Discover Global Society, the study, Gig informal workers and changing work culture in Kashmir, examines how digital platforms and short-term employment arrangements are reshaping the region’s labour market.

Based on interviews with gig workers engaged in food and grocery delivery, freelancing, teaching and taxi driving, the research identifies six major challenges and experiences: income instability, platform control mechanisms, lack of social security, perceived flexibility, region-specific uncertainties and coping strategies.

The researchers argue that gig work has emerged as an important livelihood option in Kashmir, where formal employment opportunities are limited and economic disruptions frequently affect people’s ability to earn. However, they caution that the expansion of such work has not been accompanied by adequate safeguards for workers. The study found that income insecurity was the most frequently reported concern among participants, followed by the influence of digital platforms over work allocation, payments and performance assessments.

The paper was authored by Shakeel Ahmad Sofi (Oxford Business College); Shabir Ahmad Najar and Wakar Amin Zargar (University of Kashmir); Showkat Hussain Gani (King Saud University, Saudi Arabia); Fayyaz Qureshi (University of Wales Trinity Saint David, UK); Azadeh Amoozegar (INTI University College, Malaysia); Sarwar Khawaja (Oxford Business College, UK); Lama Ahmad (Applied Science Private University, Jordan); Shouket A. Tilwani (Prince Sattam Bin Abdulaziz University, Saudi Arabia); and Bilal Ahmad Khan (Centre for Human Well-being Research and Rehabilitation Centre, Srinagar).

Income Insecurity 

The study recorded instances of income instability in the interview responses, making it the most frequently reported theme. Workers described earnings that fluctuated depending on seasonal demand, the availability of assignments and changes in platform incentives. One food and grocery delivery worker told researchers that some weeks brought enough money to meet household expenses, while others left him earning barely half of what he needed.

The participant said that during periods of low demand, he sometimes sacrificed his own necessities to provide for his family. The uncertainty, he added, made it difficult to plan household expenditure or save money. Another delivery worker described how longer working hours did not necessarily translate into predictable earnings, as algorithms continued to determine the availability of assignments.

The researchers found that even those engaged in gig work full-time could not rely on a consistent monthly income. Sudden changes in demand and incentive structures could leave workers facing unexpected financial losses.

Algorithmic Earnings

The second most frequently reported concern was platform control, which appeared 24 times in the interview analysis. Participants complained about opaque task-allocation systems, changes in commission rates without prior notice and rating mechanisms that could affect their access to work.

A taxi driver interviewed for the study said a single poor customer rating or complaint could reduce the number of assignments he received for an entire week. The driver described platform algorithms as a “black box”, saying workers had little understanding of how decisions were made and few opportunities to challenge them.

A freelance worker also reported changes in the share of earnings retained by platforms. According to the participant, the amount received had fallen from 60 per cent to 40 per cent in different months, making financial planning difficult. The researchers said these experiences reflected an imbalance of power between workers and digital platforms, with workers having limited information about decisions that directly affected their livelihoods.

Health Insurance 

The absence of social security was the third major concern, accounting for 17 mentions in the interviews. Workers reported having no health insurance, paid sick leave or reliable protection against sudden account suspensions. The study found that illness or an accident could immediately interrupt their earnings, leaving them without an institutional safety net.

A participant working as a teacher told researchers that falling ill meant earning nothing, as there was no health coverage or paid leave. A taxi driver similarly said platforms could suspend accounts following complaints or disagreements, sometimes without providing adequate explanations.

The study noted that workers had limited access to formal grievance mechanisms and social protection during illness, accidents or periods when they were unable to work.

Flexibility 

Despite these difficulties, flexibility remained an important reason workers continued in the gig economy. The study recorded 15 mentions of perceived flexibility. Participants valued the ability to choose their working hours and balance employment with family responsibilities, education and other commitments.

A food delivery worker said flexible schedules allowed him to work around household responsibilities and care for his children, something he believed would be difficult in a conventional office job. A participant involved in teaching said the arrangement allowed time for personal commitments and online learning, although the uncertainty of earnings meant constantly searching for additional work. The researchers observed that this flexibility was not necessarily equivalent to complete independence. Workers’ choices remained influenced by customer demand, platform incentives and the availability of assignments.

Economic Conditions 

The study also examined how the region’s economic conditions influence participation in gig work. This theme appeared 13 times in the interview analysis. Participants said digital services, including food and grocery delivery, transportation, tutoring and other services, were creating new earning opportunities while improving access to services for residents and helping local businesses reach customers.

The researchers noted that gig work offered young people and students an opportunity to earn money in a labour market where conventional employment opportunities were limited. However, they argued that regional economic uncertainty and disruptions could make workers more vulnerable because they had fewer alternative livelihood options.

The study also found that workers were developing their own methods to manage these risks. This theme appeared 10 times in the interviews. Some participants worked across multiple platforms, adjusted their schedules to coincide with peak demand and diversified the services they offered. Others relied on informal networks of fellow workers to exchange information about busy locations, customer behaviour and ways to reduce unproductive working hours.

One taxi driver said he used three applications to maintain a steady flow of assignments when one platform failed to provide sufficient work. The researchers described these practices as evidence of workers’ ability to adapt to an uncertain employment environment.

Labour Protections

The researchers have called for region-sensitive labour policies, stronger regulation of digital platforms and social protection measures covering all gig workers. They argue that platforms should make their algorithms and payment structures more transparent, provide clear procedures for resolving complaints and ensure that workers are not unfairly penalised through customer ratings or unexplained account suspensions.

The study also recommends fair remuneration, minimum wages and better institutional support to make platform-based employment more sustainable. It says government agencies, digital companies, workers and local communities all have a role in improving working conditions.

The researchers further suggest that workers should be encouraged to develop multiple income sources, improve their digital skills and build peer-support networks to reduce their dependence on individual platforms.

Study Style

The research adopted a qualitative exploratory approach and used purposive sampling to interview 14 gig workers in selected urban and peri-urban areas of Kashmir. The participants included five food and grocery delivery workers, four taxi drivers, three teachers and two freelancers.

Of the 14 participants, 13 were men and one was a woman. Nine had two years of experience in gig work, three had one year and two had three years. Interviews were conducted in Kashmiri, Urdu and English, according to participants’ preferences. Each interview lasted approximately one hour. Researchers transcribed and translated the interviews into English before analysing them using NVivo 12 software and reflexive thematic analysis.

The researchers have acknowledged limitations in the study, particularly its small sample size, the predominance of male participants and its focus on one geographical area. They said the findings cannot automatically be generalised to other regions and called for future research involving more women and disadvantaged groups, comparisons across different regions and long-term studies of workers’ employment experiences.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here