SRINAGAR: The Jammu Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has dismissed an appeal challenging the conferment of ownership rights over 5 kanals and 6 marlas of agricultural land in Verinag, holding that the rights of the original tillers under the Jammu and Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976, could not be displaced through a subsequent private agreement between the landlord and another person.
A Division Bench of Justice Sanjeev Kumar and Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani, while dismissing the Letters Patent Appeal (LPAOW No. 119/2015) on November 12, 2026, upheld the findings of the Single Judge, the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms and the J&K Special Tribunal, which had recognised the claim of the original tenants’ successors over the disputed land.
The court held that an agreement under Section 12 of the Agrarian Reforms Act could be executed only between an ex-owner and a prospective owner, and only in relation to payment of an agreed amount or an agreed apportionment of land. Such an agreement could not precede the attestation of a mutation under Section 4 of the Act.
“An agreement under Section 12 of the Agrarian Reforms Act can only be entered into between an ex-owner and a prospective owner,” the Bench observed, explaining that the expression ‘ex-owner’ itself presupposed that a mutation under Section 4 had already been attested.
The dispute concerned 5 kanals and 6 marlas of land falling under Survey No. 2205 in Tehsil Verinag, which was originally recorded in the ownership of Brij Lal.
According to the revenue records, the land was in the cultivating possession of Rasool, father of the private respondents, during Kharif 1971 and had remained in his possession from Kharif 1970 to Kharif 1980. However, in 1980, the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants came to be recorded as a tenant over the land.
On November 30, 1982, Brij Lal and the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants executed an agreement purportedly under Section 12 of the Agrarian Reforms Act, through which the former was shown to have surrendered his ownership rights over the land in favour of the latter. The agreement was attested by the Tehsildar Agrarian Reforms, Qazigund.
The agreement, however, was executed before any mutation under Section 4 of the Act had been attested. Subsequently, Mutation No. 1870 was attested, vesting the land in the State under Section 4 and showing the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants as the prospective owner. This was followed by Mutation No. 2460 under Section 8, through which ownership rights were conferred upon him.
Aggrieved by these mutations, the private respondents approached the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Anantnag, exercising the powers of Commissioner Agrarian Reforms. On November 12, 2007, the authority set aside both mutations and remanded the matter to the Tehsildar concerned for a fresh inquiry and orders in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the rules framed thereunder.
Following the remand, the Tehsildar, Dooru, attested Mutation No. 3159 on October 31, 2008, under Section 4 of the Act, in favour of the private respondents.
The predecessor-in-interest of the appellants challenged the fresh mutation before the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Anantnag, but the appeal was dismissed on September 25, 2009, upholding the Tehsildar’s decision.
A subsequent revision petition before the J&K Special Tribunal was also dismissed on November 28, 2013. The predecessor-in-interest of the appellants then approached the High Court through a writ petition, OWP No. 1855 of 2013, challenging the orders passed by the revenue authorities and the Tribunal.
On June 9, 2015, a Single Judge dismissed the writ petition, holding that the revenue records established the continuous cultivating possession of Rasool during the relevant period, including Kharif 1971, which was the statutory cut-off period under the Agrarian Reforms Act.
The Single Judge also found that the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants was neither in actual physical cultivation of the land during Kharif 1971 nor had the mandatory procedure prescribed under Rule 4 of the J&K Agrarian Reforms Rules, 1977, been followed to correct the corresponding Khasra Girdawari entry.
Challenging the Single Judge’s decision, the appellants argued before the Division Bench that the land had been recorded as banjar, or uncultivable, during Kharif 1971, and therefore neither the private respondents nor anyone else could have personally cultivated it during that period.
Their counsel also contended that the revenue entry bila lagan bawajah banjar, indicating the absence of rent on account of the land being barren, established that no landlord-tenant relationship had come into existence. On this basis, they argued that the private respondents were not entitled to claim ownership under Sections 4 and 8 of the Act.
The appellants further questioned the findings of the revenue authorities and the Single Judge regarding the possession of the land during the statutory cut-off period.
However, the Division Bench found the arguments unconvincing, pointing out that the appellants’ own claim was inconsistent with their contention that the land was barren in 1971.
“If we were to accept the argument of the learned counsel for the appellants that the land was banjar (unculturable) in the year 1971, it remains unexplained as to how the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants could simultaneously be shown as a tiller in cultivating possession in Kharif 1971,” the court observed.
The Bench further held that if the appellants maintained that their predecessor was cultivating the land as a tenant in Kharif 1971 but his name had not been correctly reflected in the revenue records, they were required to raise the objection before a Revenue Officer not below the rank of Tehsildar at the time of attestation of the mutation under Section 4.
The court emphasised that any such objection had to be examined in accordance with Rule 4 of the J&K Agrarian Reforms Rules, 1977, which mandates an opportunity of being heard to all stakeholders, particularly the landlord and the person already recorded as the tenant in cultivating possession of the land.
“Obviously, this did not happen in the present case,” the Bench observed, adding that the Section 4 mutation had instead been directly attested in favour of the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants by showing him as being in cultivating possession during Kharif 1971. The subsequent mutation under Section 8 had then conferred ownership rights upon him.
The court held that both mutations had rightly been set aside by the appellate authority and the J&K Special Tribunal.
It also noted that after the matter was remanded, the Tehsildar reconsidered the case on the basis of the Khasra Girdawari entry for Kharif 1971 and attested a fresh mutation under Section 4 in favour of the private respondents. That decision was subsequently upheld by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms, Anantnag, as well as the Special Tribunal.
Taking note of the concurrent findings recorded by the revenue authorities and the Single Judge, the Division Bench found no grounds to interfere with the impugned judgment.
“We also see no reason or justification to take a view different from the one taken by the Writ Court. We concur with view taken and findings of fact returned by the Writ Court, and find no merit in this appeal,” the Bench said.
Accordingly, the court dismissed the appeal, thereby upholding the earlier orders recognising the rights of the private respondents over the disputed agricultural land.
The appellants were represented by Senior Advocate M.Y. Bhat, assisted by Advocates Urba Nazir and Sajid Ahmad, while Advocate Vaseem Aslam appeared for the respondents.













